BBB REVIEWS: Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress

Home > BETTER BEDS > BBB REVIEWS > BBB REVIEWS: Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress

BBB REVIEWS: Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress


Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress

BetterBedderBureau | Verdict |

  • Three firmness options at average price-points for most
  • Some squeaks and creaks, but the Signature is not particularly noisy.

·         Three firmness options

·         Average price-point

·         Free shipping to the contiguous U.S.

·         Discounts for military personnel, first responders, teachers, and students


·         Some potential for off-gassing

·         Most models are relatively heavy and difficult to move

·         30-night break-in period for required sleep trial

Ready to Buy?

[link to manufacturer] [link to shareasale] [link to amazon affiliation]

BetterBedderBureau |Findings |

Brooklyn Bedding currently offers six individual mattress models as well.  The Brooklyn Signature is a hybrid mattress available in three firmness levels: ‘Soft,’ ‘Medium,’ and ‘Firm.’ It is constructed with gel-infused polyfoam and standard polyfoam comfort layers, as well as a quilted foam cover for added cushioning. The mattress also has pocketed coils and a high-density polyfoam base layer for added support.

Brooklyn Bedding offers a wide selection of mattresses in terms of composition, firmness, thickness, and price-point. Read on to learn more about Brooklyn Bedding, including our sleeper and performance ratings for each mattress, the company’s ordering and delivery policies, and information about sleep trials and warranty coverage.

[link to manufacturer] [link to shareasale] [link to amazon affiliation]



What Type of Sleeper Is Best Suited for a Brooklyn Bedding Mattress?

Based on our customer feedback, the Brooklyn Bedding mattresses have received the following grades among sleepers of different weights and preferred sleep positions. Please note that these ratings are subjective, and that everyone has varying experiences on different mattresses. Sleeper comfort and spinal support are the most important factors when it comes to selecting a mattress.

For more information on sleeping positions please see our guides for side, back, stomach and combination sleepers.

Our testing process found the Brooklyn Bedding line should also be great for you if…

  • You tend to sleep hot
  • You want a mattress that balances conforming and responsiveness
  • You prefer beds that are thicker than average

[link to manufacturer] [link to shareasale] [link to amazon affiliation]

All the details

FIRMNESS 3.5 (Soft)

5.5 (Medium)

7.5 (Firm)

Durability 4 – The Signature is very well built using top notch materials, especially for the price point, and should last at least 8 years with regular use
Motion Isolation 4 – Due to its 4″ all-foam comfort system, the Signature isolates and minimizes motion better than most hybrids.
Off-gassing 4 – Some off-gassing is to be expected from the Signature, but the smells ae neither stronger nor more persistent than those produced by other mattresses with thick foam layers.
Conforming 4 – The Signature offers close conforming and good pressure relief; multiple firmness options allow buyers to select a conforming level that works best for them.
Sex 4 – The Signature is fairly responsive and should be sufficiently bouncy for most couples.
Temperature Neutrality 4 – Good airflow throughout the coil layer allows the Signature to sleep cool and comfortable for most.
Edge Support 4 – The Signature’s pocketed coil and high-density polyfoam base layers reinforce the mattress well and help reduce sinkage along the edges.
Noise 3 – Some squeaks and creaks are to be expected, but the Signature is not particularly noisy.
Light side sleeper under 130 LBS 4
Average side sleeper between 130 LBS – 230 LBS 4
Heavy side sleeper over 230 LBS 3
Light back sleeper under 130 LBS 4
Average back sleeper between 130 LBS – 230 LBS 4
Heavy back sleeper over 230 LBS 4
Light stomach sleeper under 130 LBS 3
Average stomach sleeper between 130 LBS – 230 LBS 3
Heavy stomach sleeper over 230 LBS 3
Firmness Rating 3.5 (Soft)

5.5 (Medium)

7.5 (Firm)

Thickness 11 1/2″
Support Core Components 6″ Pocketed Coils

1″ HD Polyfoam

Comfort Layer Components 2″ Gel-infused Polyfoam

2″ Polyfoam

Cover Components Quilted Polyfoam with Cotton Top
Twin 38W” x 75L” x 11 ½”
Twin Extra Long (XL) 38W” x 80L” x 11 ½”
Full 54″W x 75L” x 11 ½”
Queen 60W” x 80L” x 11 ½”
King 76W” x 80L” x 11 ½”
California King 72W” x 84L” x 11 ½”
Twin $599
Twin Extra Long (XL) $699
Full $849
Queen $949
King $1249
California King $1249
Sleep trial 120 Nights
Refund Full
Warranty 10-year nonprorated
Warranty Transfer Non-Transferable
Delivery Brooklyn Bedding mattresses are compressed, vacuum sealed, and boxed for shipping
Availability Brooklyn Bedding ships mattresses anywhere in the United States and Canada.
White Glove Delivery Not Available
Old Mattress Removal Not Available
Customer Service 8 out of 10 owner experiences show customers have had a positive experience with Brooklyn Bedding, irrespective of whether or not they liked their mattress.
Company History Brooklyn Bedding, LLC was founded in 2009; its parent company, R&S Mattress, first launched in 1995. The company’s latest product line launched in 2018.
BBB Rating Not Available
Physical Stores Brooklyn Bedding operates 17 brick-and-mortar showrooms in Arizona, as well as two locations in Utah. A full store map is found on the Brooklyn Bedding website.
Phone 1-888-210-8751


[link to manufacturer] [link to shareasale] [link to amazon affiliation]

Disclosure | Our Review Process | This BetterBedderBureau Review is a collation of over 400 verified customer experiences from more than 20 unique sources and spent over 40 hours testing in an independent lab for this review. This research is supported by you, our readers, through our independently chosen links.­­

By |2019-01-15T03:43:06+00:00January 7th, 2019|BBB REVIEWS, BETTER BEDS|Comments Off on BBB REVIEWS: Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress